2024
Last updated:
Our Recommended Top 8
We did the research for you!
Licensing- User Reviews
- Mystery Shopping Calls
Our goal is to connect people with the best local professionals. We scored Columbus Pet Insurance Companies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.
14199Reviewed
8522Curated
8Top Picks
Learn about our selection process.
Providers
=
Featured Provider
License: 10139904
(62)Why choose this provider?
Penn Summit Insurance Agency LLC has been serving clients in Columbus for over 14 years. It offers specialty pet insurance policies that include coverage options for veterinary bills in case of illnesses, accidents, and other medical needs. It helps pet owners choose insurance coverage for pets from a selection of carriers. It also provides insurance solutions for personal and business needs. It represents various insurance companies, including Amerisafe, Acuity Insurance, and Progressive. The independent agency is a member of the Fayette Chamber of Commerce.
License: 1019118
Expertise.com Rating
Why choose this provider?
Sara Smucker is an American Family Insurance agent based in Westerville. Her agency provides various products, such as pet insurance, which covers hospitalization, surgery, emergency and specialty care, and prescription drugs to treat unexpected pet illnesses and injuries. Her team builds policies that best address clients' needs and assists them during claims. Smucker and her team serve individuals and families in the metro and surrounding communities, including Columbus. She is also licensed in Arizona, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, and Oregon.
- Policy Bundle Discount
License: 32304
Expertise.com Rating
Review Sources
- 4.8 (21)
Why choose this provider?
Wiles Insurance Agency serves clients in Columbus and its surrounding areas. The firm represents different carriers and offers pet insurance policies to provide coverage for veterinary treatment and medication costs in case of illnesses and injuries. Its other personal lines include auto, flood, homeowners’, individual life, renters’, and personal umbrella plans. It also customizes business packages to assist customers with reducing financial risks, such as apartment building owners', contractors', commercial property, and general liability insurance. Wiles Insurance Agency was established in 2004.
- Policy Bundle Discount
License: 1068428
Expertise.com Rating
Why choose this provider?
Adam Deel is a State Farm insurance agent who caters to the residents of Columbus and its surrounding metros. He offers an assortment of policies, including pet, life, health, hospital income, and Medicare supplement. He also provides products such as homeowners’, renters’, condo, property, auto, and business plans. In addition, he handles annuities, mutual funds, banking, and surety and fidelity bonds. Adam has more than a decade’s worth of experience in the insurance industry.
- Policy Bundle Discount
License: 3896
Why choose this provider?
Dostal & Kirk provides Columbus pet owners with pet insurance policies from a selection of national carriers. Regardless of the source of the policy, the agency deploys local adjusters to promptly attend to claims so that pets' veterinary needs may be addressed efficiently. Dostal & Kirk also offers farm insurance policies, including an equine insurance protection plan. It offers other personal and business lines of insurance, as well as financial planning and wealth management services. Jeffrey A. Kirk merged his business with The Auck Dostal Agency in 2009 to form Dostal & Kirk. He has been in the insurance industry since 1981. He also holds Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter and Certified Insurance Counselor designations.
- Policy Bundle Discount
License: 1101932
Expertise.com Rating
Why choose this provider?
Sokol Eisenberg Insurance caters to individuals, families, and businesses in the Columbus metro and the surrounding communities. It helps clients protect their animals by offering pet insurance policies. It also provides auto, disability, health, home, life, and long-term care insurance plans. In addition, protection plans for businesses and employee benefits programs are available. The agency is a member of the Ohio Insurance Agents Association. Adam Eisenberg, one of its owners, has more than 25 years of experience in the industry.
- Policy Bundle Discount
License: 39398
Why choose this provider?
Located in Hilliard, Byrd Insurance assists residents of Columbus in looking for pet protection policies. Owner Tom Byrd, who has been in the industry since 1998, partners with Firefly in catering to paw parents by presenting them with options like Pets Best policies from Progressive and dog grooming policies from Foremost. He informs them about the policies' robust coverage like accidents, hereditary conditions, and prescriptions. Byrd can also accommodate other features to add to the coverage, such as dental cleaning and vaccines.
- Policy Bundle Discount
License: 1275523
Expertise.com Rating
Review Sources
- 4.9 (39)
Why choose this provider?
Mike Mathers is a State Farm Insurance agent serving Columbus and the surrounding communities. He offers customizable pet insurance policies for different breeds of cats and dogs focusing on their medical needs. His team works with Trupanion to provide coverage options for pets' illnesses, injuries, medications, breed-specific conditions, and treatments and procedures. Mathers has more than 20 years of leadership and customer service experience. He also provides notary public services and supports the Worthington Chamber of Commerce.
- Policy Bundle Discount
Compare our Top Pet Insurance Companies
| Name | Expertise Rating | Address | Promotions | Learn more |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Penn Summit Insurance Agency LLC | 2989 National Pike, Chalk Hill, PA15421 | View More | ||
| Sara Smucker | 918 Eastwind Dr, Westerville, OH43081 | View More | ||
| Wiles Insurance Agency | 348 Granville St, Suite E, Gahanna, OH43230 | View More | ||
| Adam Deel | 1288 Bethel Road, Columbus, OH43220 | View More | ||
| Dostal & Kirk | 120 S. Sandusky Ave., Bucyrus, OH44820 | View More | ||
| Sokol Eisenberg Insurance | 1620 E Broad St 103, Columbus, OH43203 | View More | ||
| Byrd Insurance | 3602 Main Street, Hilliard, OH43026 | View More | ||
| Mike Mathers | 1000 High St Ste H, Worthington, OH43085 | View More |
FAQs
What factors should Columbus residents consider when choosing pet insurance policies?
Residents of Columbus looking for pet insurance should be aware of the various plans available, including those that cover unexpected pet conditions, accidents, and expenses associated with routine preventive care. Pet owners must also consider their preferred method of reimbursem*nt. Furthermore, before making a commitment, they must ensure a thorough understanding of the plan's inclusions and exclusions.
How important is pet insurance for Columbus residents who are on Medicaid?
Exploring pet insurance provides a practical way for Columbus pet guardians to manage their pet care expenses, even if they are on Medicaid. It enables pet caregivers to offset veterinary costs and provide excellent care for their pets on a tight budget. Individuals can also look into low-cost pet care options through local animal shelters, rescue organizations, and animal welfare associations.
Which insurance companies are popular among Columbus pet owners?
Trupanion and Nationwide are two popular pet insurance companies in Columbus. Trupanion provides a single comprehensive plan that covers unexpected illnesses and injuries. Furthermore, it allows pet owners to tailor their monthly premiums based on a sliding scale that changes based on their chosen deductibles and scope of coverage. Nationwide, on the other hand, offers a wide range of plans, from protection against unexpected health issues and injuries to options that include coverage for routine preventive care.
What is the average monthly cost of pet insurance in Columbus?
Pet insurance costs $41 per month on average for Columbus residents who own a three-year-old mixed-breed dog. The cost of treating active hepatitis ranges between $1,000 and $7,500, while the cost of treating corneal dystrophy ranges between $2,000 and $3,000. Pricing for pet insurance is determined by factors such as the pet's breed, age, and geographical location.
What do pet insurance plans in Columbus cover?
Pet insurance plans in Columbus typically cover a wide range of veterinary expenses such as illnesses, unexpected accidents, surgeries, hospitalization, and prescription drugs. Pet insurance not only manages pet owners' unexpected veterinary costs, but it also reimburses pets' medical expenses up to 100%. This reduces financial stress for pet parents.
Find top Pet Insurance Companies nearby
- Ohio
- Dayton, OH
- Cincinnati, OH
- Akron, OH
Other top picks in your area
- Mortgage Refinance in Columbus, OH
- Credit Repair in Columbus, OH
- Homeowners Insurance Agency in Columbus, OH
- Car Insurance Agency in Columbus, OH
