18 Sophisticated Women’s Black Loafers That Don’t Sacrifice Comfort (2024)

Franco Sarto's beautiful patent leather penny loafers feature an almond toe and contrast stitching along the lug sole. They also have a durable rubber grip sole that provides traction to prevent slipping. Available in sizes 6 - 11.

Madewell's bestselling driver loafers are made with a full-grain black leather upper and anti-slip sole. This slip-on style features a stitched moc toe and penny-keeper strap. Available in sizes 5 - 10.5

Birdies' Vesper loafer has a round toe shape and subtle top-stitch detailing. It's made with soft suede that's pre-broken-in so you can wear them straight out of the box. There's a barely-there heel and no-slip rubber sole. Plus, you'll get Birdies' signature seven-layer comfort footbed. Available in sizes 5 - 12.

Naturalizer is known for comfortable shoes, and the Darry black leather loafers come through with cushy Contour+ technology. These feature a one-inch all-around platform and 2 1/4-inch block heel for added lift and support. Available in black smooth or patent leather, sizes 5 - 11.

Free People's black penny loafers are made from a semi-shine, smooth leather with a grippy rubber lug sole. Available in sizes 6 - 11.

Designed by podiatrist Caroline McCulloch, these have signature footbeds to add support throughout the heel, arch, and forefoot to help prevent and alleviate foot pain. As an added bonus, they're crafted with premium leather and feature a slip-resistant sole. Available in sizes 6 - 12.

These glossy black penny loafers have contrast stitch detailing around the half-inch anti-slip rubber sole. Available in sizes 5.5 - 10.

Featured in this year's Favorite Things List, Tory Burch's rainproof loafers can be worn just about anywhere. As Oprah said, “Such a smart idea—a classic loafer that’s waterproof and just right for days of running errands.”

André Assous's timeless penny loafer offers thoughtful details like elastic heel trim for an easy-on as well as a cushioned footbed. Plus, the lug sole is super lightweight and adds plenty of traction to prevent slipping. Available in sizes 5 - 11.

When it comes to loafers, G.H. Bass are the original brand that started it all. The Whitney style is one of the most perfect penny loafers that we've seen. It's made from premium glossy leather with a cushioned insole, anti-slip outer lug sole, and penny slot detailing. Available in sizes 5 - 11.

Each Vionic shoe has an arch-supporting and body-aligning liner that has been given the stamp of approval by the American Podiatric Medical Association. These black suede penny loafers are designed to collapse and fit perfectly flat in your luggage. Available in sizes 5 - 11.

Everlane's slip-on style loafer mules offer a stylish menswear-take with details like a moc toe silhouette, subtle stitching, and traditional penny cutout. Available in sizes 5 - 11.

These vegan leather loafers feature a sleek almond moc toe and 1.5-inch treaded block heel. Journee Collection's Tru Comfort Foam insole adds underfoot cushioning. Available in sizes 5.5 - 12.

Invest in a timeless staple that will never go out of style: these gorgeous Gucci loafers. Crafted from an incredibly soft leather, these work with the heel folded down as a slipper or up as a loafer. Available in sizes 4 - 12.

These faux-black-patent-leather loafers feature a round moc toe and penny keeper detailing. The SoftSystem footbed adds cushion, while a small black heel gives support. Available in sizes 5 - 11 in medium and wide sizing.

Marc Fisher's Milton penny loafers are well-made and ideal for everyday wear. Available in sizes 5 - 12.

Stuart Weitzman's black leather loafers feature a pretty almond toe and 20mm platform for added comfort. Available in smooth and patent leather, as well as sizes 5.5 - 12.

These black leather loafer mules are as sleek as it gets with an almond toe and jewelry-like gold bar detail. Available in black smooth or patent leather; and sizes 4 - 14, as well as 6 - 9.5 Wide.